@Bartleby: Thanks for participating! Well, especially the mathematical edge got my attention. But I’ve also never found something promising.

Hi @Bartleby!

Thanks for joining in. You’re right: my intention was not to be mean, just honest.

Solidarity? Yes, and a bit more: for me, as a coder, I consider it a question of honour to pay my fellow coder respect and give him (or her) the credits he deserved for his work if I modify and republish somebody else’s code. This is even more…[Read more]

@Bartleby:

That’s a good question, and the answer obviously is no. If price is trending strongly, counter-trend price action will hardly ever hit the boundary for an entry signal. If this happens, it might be more interesting to look for confirmation of a reversal.

That simple asymmetric feature only makes sense during very weak trends, or…[Read more]

Thanks @Bartleby:

Ohh yes: sorry, I forgot that detail in my change log.

I couldn’t resist correcting the mistyped ‘isPeakThroughChange’ to ‘isPeakTroughChange’ in my version. I forgot to mention that.

s.

My Peak and Trough indicator to test and check. Single TF for the moment, triple TF needs some code cleanup.

The EA will only need one of the functions: getClearState()

Place .mqh in your Include folder and compile.

Once this is approved to be ok I will post in the main thread including some remarks for @vlanfx to ensure for proper integration…[Read more]

As I understand it, peak and through areas are defined by relative positions of Highs and Lows. And as long as a candle is being formed, it’s High or Low can change. So only after the candle is Closed, can we know for sure that a through has changed into peak. @GG53 which Close do you mean: highest Close of the area, or Close of the candle w…[Read more]

As I understand it, peak and through areas are defined by relative positions of Highs and Lows. And as long as a candle is being formed, it’s High or Low can change. So only after the candle is Closed, can we know for sure that a through has changed into peak. @GG53 which Close do you mean: highest Close of the area, or Close of the candle w…[Read more]

@slicken, @johnbaag, @Bartleby, thanks for contributing. I will look into it and post bugfix version later on.

Meanwhile, has anybody thought about how to implement these ideas from GG53:

As I understand it, peak and through areas are defined by relative positions of Highs and Lows. And as long as a candle is being formed, it’s High or Low…[Read more]

@NSCL K THANKS BROTHER I RESPECT UR DECISION

@BARTLEBY

I THINK ITS I OLD INDICATOR WHICH IS AVAILABLE ON FF WITH SOME MODIFICATION (MADE AUTOMATIC DETECT THREE POINTS AND PLOT LINE)
I HAVE MANUAL ONE WITH ME if our expert have time plz they can make it available to all friends

as i understand ruls

for sell tgt we have to chose thee point

1…[Read more]

@NSCL K THANKS BROTHER I RESPECT UR DECISION

@BARTLEBY

I THINK ITS I OLD INDICATOR WHICH IS AVAILABLE ON FF WITH SOME MODIFICATION (MADE AUTOMATIC DETECT THREE POINTS AND PLOT LINE)
I HAVE MANUAL ONE WITH ME

Great idea, @Bartleby! Subscribed!

@Bartleby: I can provide some coding skills. Like to give it a try?